“Between Legal Briefs and Hymns: The Double Consciousness of Black Liberation”

The Legal Genius Behind Brown v. Board of Education

When Thurgood Marshall stood before the Supreme Court in 1954 to argue Brown v. Board of Education, he relied on a legal foundation built by Dr. Pauli Murray. Yet, for many, her name remains unfamiliar. A groundbreaking lawyer, activist, writer, and later an Episcopal priest, Pauli Murray’s influence on civil rights and gender equality was profound, even if history has not always given her the recognition she deserves.

Pauli Murray was a visionary long before the world was ready to listen. In the 1940s, she developed a legal argument against segregation that would later become the backbone of Brown v. Board of Education. While studying at Howard University School of Law—where she was the only woman in her class—Murray wrote a paper advocating that segregation violated the 14th Amendment’s Equal Protection Clause. At the time, the prevailing strategy in the fight against segregation was to push for “equal” facilities rather than challenge segregation itself. Murray, however, argued for a direct attack on the separate-but-equal doctrine established by Plessy v. Ferguson.

Marshall and his team later used these arguments in Brown, helping to overturn legal segregation in schools. Though she wasn’t present at the counsel’s table, Murray’s ideas helped shape the legal strategies that changed America.

“Law Alone Would Not Give Us the Answers”

Beyond the Law: A Moral and Ethical Reckoning

Despite her success in law and activism, Murray came to realize that the issues facing humanity were not just legal or political but deeply moral and ethical. The law could provide structure and enforcement, but it could not change hearts and minds on its own. Looking back on her life’s work, Murray reflected:

“It seems to me, as I look back over my life, that all of these problems of human rights in which I have been involved were moral and spiritual problems. And I saw that the profession to which I had devoted my life—law—would not give us the answers. And I asked myself, what to do with the time you have left? I was being pointed in the direction of the priesthood or service to the church.”

At the age of 62, Murray entered seminary and in 1977, at 75 years old, she became the first Black woman ordained as an Episcopal priest. This was a milestone for both racial and gender equality in religious leadership.

The Modern Backlash—A Moral Crisis, Not a Legal One

Today, we are witnessing a coordinated assault on DEI (Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion) programs, affirmative action, and voting rights—all hard-won gains of the Civil Rights Movement. Politicians and pundits dismiss these efforts as “reverse racism” or “unfair advantages,” ignoring the historical and systemic barriers that necessitated them in the first place.

But this is not just a policy debate—it is a moral crisis.

As Toni Morrison once said:

if you can only be tall because somebody is on their knees, then you have a serious problem. And my feeling is that white people have a very, very serious problem and they should start thinking about what they can do about it. Take me out of it.

Black Americans have spent centuries fighting for justice, educating, protesting, and even dying for equality. Yet, the burden of solving racism should not fall on us. White America must confront its own history, its fears, and its resistance to true equity.

Our Moral Calling – A Look Inward

While we cannot—and should not—carry the weight of white America’s moral failures, we do have our own spiritual and ethical questions to ponder.

1. We Are Enough

For too long, Black excellence has been measured by proximity to whiteness—assimilation, respectability politics, and the pursuit of validation from oppressive systems. But our ancestors knew their worth without permission. The Slave Bible, with only 232 chapters (compared to the full Bible’s 1189), deliberately excluded the story of Moses demanding Pharaoh, “Let my people go!” Yet, they still resisted. They still dreamed. They still passed down faith, resilience, and an unshakable belief in liberation.

If they could survive with so much taken from them, what excuse do we have?

2. Unity in Black Greatness

Galatians 3:28 declares:

“There is neither Jew nor Greek, slave nor free, male nor female, for you are all one in Christ Jesus.”

This scripture is a radical call to unity beyond hierarchy. We must reject division—whether by class, skin tone, or ideology—and recognize that we are all part of a glorious legacy of Black resilience.

3. Three Ways to Open Doors

In his sermon “The Key to Open Doors,” Apostle Joshua Selman outlines how we secure our future:

1. Use Your Keys (What You Already Have)

  • Education (formal and ancestral wisdom)
  • Economic Power (supporting Black businesses, financial literacy)
  • Political Engagement (voting, running for office, holding leaders accountable)

2. Knock on Doors (Pursue Opportunities Relentlessly)

  • Demand Representation (in corporate boards, media, politics)
  • Build Coalitions (across the diaspora and with aligned movements)
  • Tell Our Stories (art, film, literature—narratives shape reality)

3. Call on God

  • Prayer and Faith—Our ancestors prayed us into existence.
  • Supernatural Strategy—Divine wisdom beyond our own understanding.
  • Moral Clarity—Knowing when to fight, when to rest, and when to rebuild.

Conclusion: The Work Continues

Pauli Murray’s life teaches us that justice requires both legal battles and moral courage. Today, as freedoms we thought were secure come under attack, we must remember:

  • We do not need permission to be great.
  • Our liberation is tied to our unity.
  • The keys are in our hands, but some doors will only open by faith.

The ancestors brought us this far with less. They are saying “We survived with 232 Bible chapters. You have 1189 + Google. What’s your excuse?” ‘Now, it’s our turn to secure the future. The question is no longer “Can we?” but “Will we?”

Published by Iris Lewis

Seeker of Knowledge, Messenger, Vocalist, Confidant

Leave a comment